The 10 Mistakes First-Time Authors Make—And What Editors Wish They Knew.

Writing a book is an act of courage. But publishing one? If you're a first-time author dreaming of seeing your name on a cover, this post is your compass. Here are the 10 biggest mistakes first-time authors make, and what editors really wish you'd know before hitting "send."

1. Writing Without Knowing Their Audience

You might think your book is “for everyone,” but publishing doesn’t work that way. Editors want authors who understand their niche.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

Define your ideal reader. Know the genre conventions. Study the market. Who reads your kind of book—and what do they expect?

2. Querying Too Early

Many authors send out their manuscripts as soon as they type "The End." That’s a mistake.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

A first draft is not a final draft. Revise ruthlessly. Beta readers and critique partners are your best pre-editors. Great writing is re-writing.

3. Ignoring Submission Guidelines

You’d be shocked how many authors submit PDFs when the guidelines ask for Word docs, or send the whole book instead of a synopsis and sample.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

Following instructions shows you’re professional and collaborative—two traits every editor values.

4. Over-Explaining or Info-Dumping

New authors often frontload backstory or world-building. Readers get lost before the story even begins.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

We want to be pulled into a scene, not a history lesson. Start with action or emotional stakes. Trust readers to catch up.

5. Weak or Confused Pitch

Your manuscript may be great—but if your pitch is unclear, it may never be read.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

Your pitch should tell us: What’s the story? Who’s it for? Why now? And no, “It’s like Harry Potter meets The Bible” doesn’t count.

6. Writing to Impress Instead of Connect

Many first-timers overwrite, using flowery language or forced metaphors.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

Clarity beats cleverness. Your job isn’t to sound smart. It’s to make readers feel something.

7. Taking Feedback Personally

Rejection stings—but interpreting editorial feedback as an attack can stall your growth.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

Editing isn’t about tearing you down. It’s about helping your story become what it’s meant to be. Stay open, stay humble.

8. Overestimating or Underestimating the Role of Marketing.

Some authors think, “If I write it, they will come.” Others panic about building a brand before they even have a draft.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

Yes, author platform matters—but story still reigns. Focus on writing a strong book, then gradually build your presence.

9. Not Reading Enough

You’d be amazed how many first-time writers haven’t read a single book in their genre in years.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

Reading is research. It teaches pacing, tone, voice, and what readers love. Don’t just write—read like your career depends on it. (It does.)

10. Giving Up Too Soon

One rejection, one bad review, one unfollow—and some authors quit.

What Editors Wish You Knew:

Persistence is a superpower. Every successful author you admire? They were once where you are. They kept going.

Being a debut author is like being a first-time traveler in a foreign country. You’ll make mistakes—and that’s okay. But if you walk into the process with humility, clarity, and curiosity, you’ll not only survive—you’ll thrive.

And editors? We're rooting for you.

Share this with a writer friend who needs to hear it. Or better yet, tag them in the comments and say: Keep going. You're doing better than you think.

‍